Should You Take Cigars Out of Plastic in Humidor: A Symphony of Smoke and Cellophane

The world of cigar aficionados is one steeped in tradition, ritual, and a deep appreciation for the finer things in life. Among the many debates that swirl around the proper care and storage of cigars, one question often arises: should you take cigars out of their plastic wrappers before placing them in a humidor? This seemingly simple query opens the door to a labyrinth of opinions, each backed by its own set of arguments, anecdotes, and sometimes, a dash of mystique.
The Case for Keeping Cigars in Plastic
Protection from Physical Damage
One of the primary reasons to leave cigars in their plastic wrappers is the protection it offers against physical damage. Cigars are delicate creations, and even the slightest bump or pressure can cause cracks or tears in the wrapper leaf. The plastic acts as a shield, safeguarding the cigar from the rigors of handling and transportation. This is particularly important for those who frequently move their cigars or share them with friends.
Maintaining Humidity Levels
Another argument in favor of keeping cigars in plastic is the role it plays in maintaining humidity levels. The plastic wrapper acts as a barrier, slowing down the exchange of moisture between the cigar and the surrounding environment. This can be beneficial in a humidor, where the goal is to maintain a consistent humidity level. By keeping the cigars in their plastic, you create a microclimate that helps to stabilize the humidity around each individual cigar.
Preventing Flavor Contamination
Cigars are known for their complex and nuanced flavors, which can be easily influenced by external factors. The plastic wrapper serves as a protective layer, preventing the cigar from absorbing odors and flavors from other cigars in the humidor. This is especially important for those who store a variety of cigars with different flavor profiles. By keeping each cigar in its own plastic wrapper, you ensure that the unique characteristics of each cigar remain intact.
The Case for Removing Cigars from Plastic
Enhanced Aging Process
One of the most compelling arguments for removing cigars from their plastic wrappers is the potential for enhanced aging. Cigars, like fine wines, can improve with age, developing deeper and more complex flavors over time. When cigars are stored without their plastic wrappers, they are able to interact more freely with the humidor environment, allowing for a more natural aging process. This can lead to a richer and more nuanced smoking experience.
Improved Air Circulation
Another benefit of removing cigars from their plastic wrappers is improved air circulation within the humidor. Proper air circulation is essential for maintaining consistent humidity levels and preventing mold growth. When cigars are stored without their plastic, air can flow more freely around them, ensuring that each cigar receives an even distribution of moisture. This can help to prevent issues such as uneven drying or over-humidification.
Aesthetic Appeal
For many cigar enthusiasts, the visual appeal of a well-stocked humidor is an important aspect of the hobby. Removing cigars from their plastic wrappers allows for a more aesthetically pleasing display, showcasing the beauty of each cigar’s wrapper leaf and band. This can enhance the overall experience of selecting and enjoying a cigar, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to the ritual.
The Middle Ground: Partial Removal
Selective Unwrapping
Some cigar aficionados choose to take a middle-of-the-road approach, selectively removing the plastic wrappers from certain cigars while leaving others intact. This allows for a balance between protection and aging, as well as the ability to tailor the storage conditions to the specific needs of each cigar. For example, cigars that are particularly delicate or prone to damage might be left in their plastic, while those that are known to benefit from aging might be unwrapped.
Seasonal Considerations
Another factor to consider is the season or climate in which the cigars are being stored. In particularly humid environments, it might be beneficial to leave cigars in their plastic wrappers to prevent over-humidification. Conversely, in drier climates, removing the plastic might help to maintain adequate moisture levels. By taking into account the specific conditions of the storage environment, cigar enthusiasts can make more informed decisions about whether to remove the plastic.
Expert Opinions and Anecdotes
The Wisdom of the Masters
Many seasoned cigar enthusiasts and experts have weighed in on the debate, offering a wealth of knowledge and experience. Some argue that the plastic wrapper is an essential part of the cigar’s journey, providing protection and stability from the moment it leaves the factory to the moment it is enjoyed. Others believe that the plastic is a hindrance, preventing the cigar from reaching its full potential. Ultimately, the decision often comes down to personal preference and the specific needs of the cigars in question.
Anecdotal Evidence
Anecdotal evidence also plays a significant role in shaping opinions on this topic. Many cigar smokers have their own stories and experiences that inform their approach to storage. Some swear by the benefits of keeping cigars in their plastic, citing instances where the wrapper saved a cigar from damage or preserved its flavor. Others have found that removing the plastic has led to a more enjoyable smoking experience, with cigars that have aged beautifully and developed complex flavors.
Practical Considerations
Storage Space
One practical consideration is the amount of storage space available in the humidor. Cigars stored without their plastic wrappers take up less space, allowing for more cigars to be stored in the same humidor. This can be particularly important for those with limited storage capacity or those who like to keep a large variety of cigars on hand.
Ease of Access
Another practical factor is the ease of access to the cigars. Cigars stored without their plastic wrappers are easier to handle and inspect, making it simpler to check for issues such as mold or uneven drying. This can be especially important for those who regularly rotate their cigars or who like to inspect their collection frequently.
Conclusion: A Matter of Personal Preference
In the end, the decision of whether to take cigars out of their plastic wrappers before placing them in a humidor is a deeply personal one. There are valid arguments on both sides, and the best approach may vary depending on the specific circumstances and preferences of the individual cigar enthusiast. Whether you choose to keep your cigars in their plastic wrappers, remove them entirely, or take a selective approach, the most important thing is to ensure that your cigars are stored in a way that allows them to be enjoyed to their fullest potential.
Related Q&A
Q: Can I store cigars in their original boxes in a humidor? A: Yes, storing cigars in their original boxes within a humidor is a common practice. The boxes can help to protect the cigars and maintain a stable environment, especially if the humidor is opened frequently.
Q: How often should I check the humidity levels in my humidor? A: It’s a good idea to check the humidity levels in your humidor at least once a week. This will help you to ensure that the environment remains stable and that your cigars are being stored under optimal conditions.
Q: Can I use a regular plastic bag to store cigars? A: While a regular plastic bag can provide some protection, it is not ideal for long-term storage. Cigars need to breathe, and a regular plastic bag can trap moisture and lead to mold growth. It’s better to use a humidor or a specialized cigar storage solution.
Q: How long can cigars be stored in a humidor? A: Cigars can be stored in a humidor for many years, and some even improve with age. However, it’s important to monitor the humidity and temperature levels regularly to ensure that the cigars remain in good condition.
Q: Should I rotate my cigars in the humidor? A: Rotating your cigars can help to ensure that they age evenly and that all cigars receive consistent humidity. It’s a good practice to rotate them every few months, especially if you have a large collection.